• About Us
• News & Events
• Investigations
• Cases
  • Access to Public Entities and Services
  • Access to Private Businesses
  • Access to Employment
  • Access to Health Care & Insurance
  • Access to Education & Testing
  • Access to Veteran Benefits
• Projects
• Publications
• Resources
• Newsletter
• Jobs & Fellowships
• Submit Intake Form
• Make a Donation

OAKLAND SUED FOR FAILURE TO INCLUDE PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES IN DISASTER PLANNING

August 9, 2007

DRA filed a lawsuit against the City of Oakland to address the City’s failure to adequately plan to meet the mass care and shelter needs of people with disabilities in an emergency. The suit highlights a national problem, and one made especially evident during Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, during which people with disabilities had their lives put at risk because of a lack of planning for this vulnerable population. The case is the first of its kind in the country.

Plaintiffs – the California Foundation for Independent Living Centers ("CFILC") , Californians for Disability Rights, Inc. ("CDR")., and Marian Gray (an Oakland taxpayer) – charge that the City of Oakland has violated federal and state civil rights laws designed to provide people with disabilities equal access to emergency shelter services. Plaintiffs are seeking only injunctive relief.

The City’s violations include:

• The failure to conduct adequate surveys of the accessibility of potential shelter sites, resulting in a list that contains many inaccessible shelters;
• The failure to revise the City’s Mass Care and Shelter Plan from the 1980s to address the needs of men, women, and children with disabilities;
• The failure to make arrangements to provide prescriptions, medical supplies and equipment, or accessible transportation to people with disabilities in an emergency.

The City of Oakland is particularly disaster prone and susceptible to a variety of emergencies, including earthquakes, fires, landslides, and terrorist attacks. Since 1983, the City of Oakland has experienced eight Presidential-declared disasters, including the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, 1991 Oakland Hills Firestorm, the 1997 El Nino winter storms, and the 1998 La Nina winter storms. During many of these disasters, the homes of Oakland residents were destroyed, requiring mass evacuations and the provision of emergency shelter services. For instance, following the Loma Prieta earthquake, more than 12,000 Oakland residents were left homeless and more than 18,000 homes were damaged. Following the 1991 Oakland Hills Firestorm, more than 3,000 homes were destroyed. United States Geological Survey scientists have concluded that there is a 62% probability of one or more major earthquakes (magnitude 6.7 or greater) striking the Bay Area between the years 2003 and 2032.

The 2000 United States Census estimated that 23% of Oakland’s population is disabled. As such, over 84,000 Oakland residents may not receive the emergency shelter services they need during an emergency.

Read More About The Lawsuit

Read the Press Release

Read the Case Fact Sheet

Read the Complaint